For many Anglicans, the words “canon law” do not exactly quicken the pulse. Canons can seem technical, procedural, and far removed from the daily work of preaching the Gospel, making disciples, caring for the vulnerable, planting churches, and worshiping Almighty God. But canon law matters precisely because, when properly in place, helps in the flourishing of all of those things that seem to be the heart of the Church’s mission to the world.
At the American Anglican Council (AAC), Anglican Governance Ministries represents one of the three principal areas of our work. Why would the AAC devote so much time and so many resources to constitutions, canons, bylaws, disciplinary procedures, and governance? Because good governance is not an end in itself. Good governance creates the conditions in which the Church can faithfully pursue her mission. Good canons promote unity, establish accountability, preserve doctrine, protect clergy and laity, and allow the Church to carry out her work in good order.
This is particularly important in the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) because of who we are and where we came from. The province was formed from dioceses, congregations, networks, and individuals representing several different streams of Anglicanism. Anglo-Catholics, evangelicals, charismatics, and others came together to form a new province. Our Constitution and Canons help hold these different streams together around a common faith and common order while reserving substantial authority to dioceses and local congregations. We deliberately did not create a highly centralized province. Instead, authority and responsibility are distributed among the Archbishop, College of Bishops, Provincial Council, Provincial Assembly, dioceses, bishops, and other bodies. That makes clear canons especially important. They tell us not simply who has authority, but where that authority begins and ends.
Good canons promote accountability.
Church authority should never be absolute. Our constitutional and canonical structures distribute responsibility among different bodies, giving each real authority while placing limits upon it. Those limitations are not impediments to ministry. They are protections for the Church. Nowhere is that more obvious than in clergy discipline. Title IV of our canons establishes the procedures by which allegations against clergy are reported, investigated, adjudicated, and appealed. Over the past several years, the ACNA undertook extensive work to reform those canons. The AAC played a significant role in that work, because we believe a mature Church must be able to pursue truth with both justice and charity.
Recent disciplinary controversies in our Province, including matters involving Archbishop Steve Wood and Bishop Derek Jones, have only underscored the importance of this work. Whatever one’s views of the particular allegations or parties involved, such difficult circumstances expose ambiguities and weaknesses in our governing structures in ways ordinary times often do not. They force us to ask whether authority is clearly defined, whether procedures are fair, whether those reporting misconduct are heard, whether those accused receive due process, and whether the Church can pursue truth transparently and faithfully. Good canons cannot guarantee that difficult situations will never occur. They can help ensure that when they do occur, the Church knows how to respond.
Good canons preserve our doctrine and order our common ministry.
The ACNA’s canonical foundations also tell us something about who we are. Our Fundamental Declarations locate our identity within the historic Anglican faith, grounded in Holy Scripture and expressed through the historic creeds, the Thirty-Nine Articles, the Book of Common Prayer, and the received Anglican tradition. The Jerusalem Declaration of 2008 likewise remains an important statement of the faith that brought so many of us together.
Canons, therefore, do more than regulate meetings and disciplinary proceedings. They help preserve the theological identity of the Church from one generation to another. They also establish common expectations for ordained ministry. Title III provides standards for discernment, formation, examination, ordination, and reception of clergy. In a province characterized by church planting and the movement of clergy between dioceses, that common order matters. A bishop receiving a priest from another ACNA diocese should have reasonable confidence in the processes by which that priest was discerned, formed, and ordained.
Good canons remember what institutions are tempted to forget.
This is especially important for a young province. Many of the people who founded the ACNA remember firsthand the painful circumstances surrounding our separation from The Episcopal Church. Congregations endured costly litigation over property. Clergy and lay leaders navigated questions involving ownership, trusts, corporate structures, episcopal authority, and financial stewardship. Those experiences shaped many of the structures we inherited and subsequently developed. But a new generation of clergy and lay leaders is entering the ACNA with no personal memory of those struggles. That is a blessing. We do not want to define ourselves forever by the battles of the past.
Nevertheless, while institutions may forget, good canons help us to remember. Clear provisions regarding property, finances, authority, discipline, and oversight preserve lessons learned at considerable cost. They allow the next generation to benefit from wisdom it did not have to acquire painfully for itself, and that institutional memory ultimately serves mission.
Good canons should free the Church for mission, not obstruct it.
Church planting, missionary jurisdictions, networks, dioceses, and congregations all need structures that allow them to grow while maintaining appropriate accountability. Canon law at its best does not create bureaucracy for bureaucracy’s sake. It establishes clear lanes so that bishops, clergy, and lay leaders can devote their attention to the work God has given them to do. Our canons also connect the ACNA with something larger than ourselves, reminding us that we did not invent Anglican polity in 2009. Our canonical structures drew upon a received Anglican tradition developed over centuries. That continuity was particularly important for a province that, from its beginning, needed to demonstrate that it is not merely a temporary protest against another church body but a Church with deep roots and, by God’s grace, a bright future.
All of this explains why the American Anglican Council invests so heavily in Anglican Governance Ministries. But this work can’t be limited to just the provincial level. The same principles that make good canons essential to the ACNA as a whole (clarity, accountability, good order, and fidelity to our shared mission) matter just as much in the governance of our dioceses and parishes. For that reason, the AAC is expanding our efforts to provide practical canonical and governance counsel throughout the Province. We are now offering complimentary 30-minute initial consultations to individuals, parishes, dioceses, and Anglican leaders who need help reviewing or interpreting canons and bylaws, addressing governance questions, or simply determining the best way forward when an issue arises. I will be available for these conversations, and where a matter requires more extensive research, document review, or ongoing assistance, the AAC can provide additional support as needed. In this way, the expertise developed through our provincial canonical work can also serve the everyday governance needs of the Church, and any proceeds from that work will help sustain the AAC’s continuing efforts to strengthen godly governance throughout the ACNA.
Our goal is simple: to help the Church govern herself faithfully so that governance serves, rather than distracts from, the mission Christ entrusted to us. Canons will never proclaim the Gospel. They will never baptize a new believer, celebrate the Eucharist, comfort the grieving, or plant a church. But wise, clear, and faithful canons help create a Church in which those things can flourish in good order, and that is why this work matters.