Christian leaders spend a great deal of time encouraging others to trust God. They preach about faith, teach about God’s sovereignty, and counsel those who are struggling to place their lives in His hands. But for those entrusted with leading congregations, ministries, and other Christian organizations, trusting God can sometimes be more difficult than they care to admit. After all, leaders are expected to lead. They are responsible for making decisions, solving problems, developing plans, and guiding others through uncertainty. When things go wrong, people look to them for answers. When challenges arise, they are expected to respond. And when the future seems uncertain, they are often the ones tasked with charting a course forward.
But somewhere amid these responsibilities, Christian leaders can begin to confuse faithfulness with control. We may believe wholeheartedly that God is sovereign while quietly acting as though the success or failure of our ministry rests entirely on our shoulders. We may pray for God’s guidance while relying primarily on our own experience, abilities, and understanding. We may even encourage others to surrender their lives to Christ while holding tightly to our own plans. This raises an uncomfortable but important question: Can we effectively lead others into a deeper trust in God if we struggle to trust Him ourselves?
BELIEVING AND TRUSTING IN GOD
In their book The Discipleship Pathway, Canon Mark Eldredge and Deacon Dollene McLemore explore this distinction in the second step of their twelve-step approach to spiritual growth: “Incline Our Hearts to God.” They explain that acknowledging God’s existence is not the same as entrusting our lives to Him. Genuine discipleship requires more than intellectual agreement with the truths of Scripture. It calls us to believe that God loves us, that He has the power to restore us, and that He can lead us forward. As they observe, “We believe just enough to acknowledge God but not enough to entrust our lives to Him.”
For Christian leaders, this distinction is especially significant. A pastor may believe that God provides for His Church while becoming consumed with anxiety over attendance and finances. A vestry may affirm the importance of prayer while approaching every decision as though strategic planning alone will determine the congregation’s future. A ministry leader may sincerely desire God’s will while finding it difficult to accept that His direction might differ from carefully developed plans. None of these responsibilities is unimportant. Planning, stewardship, and wise decision-making are essential aspects of faithful leadership, but they become spiritually dangerous when our confidence in our own abilities begins to displace our dependence on God.
Proverbs 3:5 reminds us: “Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and do not lean on your own understanding.” The passage does not suggest that understanding is unnecessary. Rather, it challenges us to recognize its limitations. Our judgment, experience, and abilities are gifts to be used in God’s service, not substitutes for trusting Him.
WHEN LEADERSHIP BECOMES AN ILLUSION OF CONTROL
One of the biblical examples explored in The Discipleship Pathway is King Nebuchadnezzar in Daniel 4. Nebuchadnezzar was an extraordinarily powerful ruler. He possessed wealth, authority, and influence on a scale few could imagine. He had also witnessed remarkable demonstrations of God’s power, but recognizing that power did not necessarily mean submitting himself to it. Standing in his royal palace, Nebuchadnezzar surveyed the greatness of Babylon and celebrated what he believed he accomplished through his own strength. His confidence rested in his position, achievements, and authority. Then everything changed. Through a profound experience of humiliation and loss, Nebuchadnezzar was brought to recognize his earthly power was neither absolute nor ultimately his own. Only after being humbled did he acknowledge God’s sovereign rule.
There is an important lesson here for Christian leaders. We may never possess the authority of Nebuchadnezzar, but we are not immune to his temptation. It is possible to become so invested in the work we are doing for God that we gradually lose sight of our dependence upon Him. Success can reinforce the illusion that our abilities are sufficient. Difficulty can produce the opposite response, convincing us that unless we work harder, plan better, or exercise greater control, everything will fall apart. In both circumstances, the underlying problem may be the same: we have begun to place too much trust in ourselves. Faithful Christian leadership requires something different. It demands humility, a willingness to acknowledge our limitations, and the courage to entrust outcomes to God even when we cannot see what lies ahead.
PREPARING OUR HEARTS FOR ADVENT
As the Church approaches Advent, we enter a season traditionally associated with preparation, repentance, and watchfulness. We prepare to celebrate the coming of Christ while looking forward to His return. For Christian leaders, this season presents an opportunity to examine not only how we are preparing our congregations, but how we are preparing our own hearts. There will be services to organize, sermons to prepare, programs to coordinate, and countless demands competing for our attention. In the busyness of preparing others for Advent and Christmas, it can become surprisingly easy to neglect our own spiritual preparation.
Perhaps one of the most important things we can do this Advent is to consider where we have stopped trusting God. Where have we become overly dependent on our own understanding? Where have we allowed anxiety about the future to overshadow confidence in God’s goodness? Where are we reluctant to surrender control because we fear what might happen if we do. The second step of The Discipleship Pathway reminds us that trust is not necessarily something we possess perfectly from the beginning. It grows as we encounter God, study His Word, recognize His faithfulness, and take small steps of obedience. We do not need to have every answer before we begin trusting Him more deeply.
At the American Anglican Council, our commitment to developing healthy leaders is rooted in the conviction that healthy ministry begins with healthy discipleship. Programs, strategies, and leadership skills all have their place, but none can replace a living relationship with Jesus Christ. This Advent, may we remember that the Church ultimately belongs to Christ, not to those entrusted with leading it. Our calling is not to control every outcome, but to lead faithfully, serve humbly, and trust the One who has called us.